Why Choose Hardwood Flooring Over Engineered

Why Choose Hardwood Flooring Over Engineered

Written by Hansen Timber Team

15th Sep 2025

When selecting flooring for your New Zealand home or commercial space, the choice between solid hardwood flooring and engineered alternatives represents one of your most important decisions. While both options serve different purposes in the market, solid hardwood flooring offers distinct advantages that make it the superior choice for many applications.

Understanding these differences helps inform better decisions for your project. As timber specialists with over 150 years of heritage in New Zealand's forestry industry, we at Hansen Timber have witnessed firsthand how solid hardwood flooring performs across generations.

Understanding the Fundamental Differences

Before exploring the advantages of solid hardwood, let's clarify what distinguishes these flooring types:

Solid Hardwood Flooring consists of planks milled from a single piece of timber, typically 18-20mm thick. Each board represents pure wood from top to bottom, showcasing the natural beauty and characteristics of the timber species.

Engineered Flooring features a thin veneer of real wood (usually 2-6mm) bonded to multiple layers of plywood or composite materials. While mimicking solid wood's appearance, its construction differs fundamentally.

The Compelling Case for Solid Hardwood

Longevity That Spans Generations

Solid hardwood flooring represents an investment in perpetuity. With proper care, these floors can last 100 years or more – we've observed original kauri and macrocarpa floors in heritage New Zealand homes that remain beautiful after more than a century. Engineered floors typically last 20-50 years depending on veneer thickness and construction quality.

The key lies in solid hardwood's refinishing capability. When wear patterns develop or styles change, solid floors can be sanded and refinished, essentially providing a brand-new floor. Most solid hardwood flooring can undergo 5-10 refinishings over its lifetime, while engineered options typically handle only 1-3 refinishings, depending on veneer thickness.

Authentic Beauty and Character

Something irreplaceable exists in the authentic beauty of solid timber. Each plank tells its story through grain patterns, natural variations, and subtle characteristics that bring character to your space. New Zealand natives like macrocarpa develop rich patinas over time, deepening in colour and beauty with age.

Solid hardwood flooring also provides superior sound and feel underfoot. The density and mass of solid timber offer better acoustic properties and a more substantial feeling when walking across the floor. This authentic experience cannot be replicated by engineered alternatives.

Superior Structural Integrity

Solid hardwood floors contribute to your building's structural integrity in ways engineered floors cannot match. The thick, solid planks provide additional strength to the subfloor system and can help level minor subfloor imperfections during installation.

In New Zealand's varied climate – from humid coastal areas to dry inland regions – solid hardwood's natural ability to expand and contract as a single unit often provides better long-term stability than engineered floors, where delamination between layers may occur over time.

Environmental Sustainability Considerations

For environmentally conscious New Zealanders, solid hardwood flooring from sustainably managed forests represents one of the most eco-friendly flooring choices available:

Carbon Storage: Solid wood floors act as carbon sinks, storing carbon throughout their extended lifetime.

Renewable Resource: When sourced from certified sustainable forests, timber remains completely renewable.

End-of-Life: At lifecycle completion, solid wood is completely biodegradable.

Manufacturing: Unlike engineered floors, solid hardwood doesn't require adhesives between layers that may off-gas over time.

Our locally sourced timber comes from sustainably managed New Zealand forests, ensuring minimal transportation emissions while supporting local forestry practices.

Long-Term Value Proposition

While solid hardwood flooring typically requires higher initial investment than engineered options, it provides superior value over its lifetime. Consider the total cost of ownership:

  • Extended lifespan of 100+ years versus 20-50 years for engineered
  • Multiple refinishing opportunities versus limited options
  • Consistent property value enhancement
  • Simple maintenance requirements without delamination risk

When factoring in replacement costs, solid hardwood flooring often proves more economical over time, beyond the added property value it provides.

Healthier Indoor Environment

Solid hardwood floors contribute to healthier indoor air quality. They don't harbour dust mites, pet dander, or other allergens like carpet, and unlike some engineered floors, they don't contain adhesives that may emit VOCs (volatile organic compounds). This makes them an excellent choice for families with allergies or respiratory sensitivities.

Design and Installation Versatility

Solid hardwood offers unmatched versatility for creative installations. Because each plank consists of solid wood throughout, various patterns – herringbone, chevron, or traditional straight lay – can be achieved without concern for veneer direction or layer exposure. Custom milling to specific widths and profiles allows achievement of your desired aesthetic.

Making the Right Choice for Your Project

Solid hardwood flooring remains the premium choice for those seeking:

  • Long-term value and durability
  • Authentic beauty and character
  • Environmental sustainability
  • Healthy indoor environments
  • Refinishing and renewal capability

Installation Considerations

To ensure optimal performance of your solid hardwood floor:

Proper Acclimatisation: Allow boards to acclimatise to your space for at least 48-72 hours before installation.

Moisture Control: Ensure appropriate subfloor moisture levels (typically below 12%).

Professional Installation: While DIY-friendly, professional installation ensures optimal results.

Appropriate Subfloor: Solid hardwood performs best over wooden subfloors or battens.

 

Hansen Timber: Your Hardwood Flooring Specialists

At Hansen Timber, we continue a tradition spanning over 150 years, providing New Zealanders with quality solid timber products that stand the test of time. Our hardwood flooring options include locally sourced macrocarpa, treated pine, and premium Blackbutt Eucalyptus.

Whether building a new home, renovating a heritage property, or creating a commercial space with enduring appeal, solid hardwood flooring offers unmatched value and beauty. Our experienced team can help you select the perfect timber species and specifications for your project.

Ready to explore solid hardwood flooring options? Contact Hansen Timber today at 09 242 3644 or visit us at 52 Eyres Road, Clevedon.

Contact Hansen Timber


Got Wood ideas? We are here to shape them.